Insights
Making the main product but drowning in by-products? Get costing under control with ERP
blog
“You send 1,000 kilograms of chicken through the processing plant to get ‘breast meat,’ but the process also churns out ‘wings, giblets, and carcasses’… The question that has Accounting and Production arguing every month is… how do we split the cost of the whole bird across each part? And if we sell off the carcasses, how should that money be recorded in the books?”
If your factory is in process manufacturing, such as meat processing, vegetable oil extraction, or chemicals, or even metal stamping that generates large amounts of “scrap,” you’re up against the challenge of managing “co-products” and “by-products.”
The frustrating reality is that in a single production order you put in one raw material but get three or four different outputs at the same time! Without a capable enough system in place, what happens is that “the main product ends up carrying the entire cost on its own.”
The financial fallout when you ignore by-products
Using manual methods or Excel to cost multi-output production usually leads to the following losses:
- The main product buckles under the cost (overcosting): If you load 100% of the material cost onto “chicken breast,” its cost goes through the roof, and Sales can no longer price it competitively.
- By-products appear free (the zero-cost illusion): With all the cost sitting on the main product, the “wings” or “scrap metal” you produce are carried in the books at zero baht. When they’re sold, management sees “100% profit,” a misleading figure that badly distorts the profit and loss statement.
- Invisible, unauditable stock: Because by-products are seen as a “freebie” from the production line, staff often don’t bother scanning them into the warehouse. They pile up behind the factory with no one knowing exactly how much there is, leaving the door open to losses, or to theft and sales that bypass the company.
Allocate costs down to the last gram with a multi-output BOM in your ERP
The lasting fix is to let the system do the complex calculations instead of people. An ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) system built for manufacturing provides powerful co-product and by-product management through three mechanisms:
1. Multi-output bill of materials (multi-output BOM)
The ERP lets you set up a one-to-many bill of materials (BOM): you put in a single raw material A, but tell the system up front that each completed run must yield 60% main product, 30% co-product, and 10% by-product (scrap). Line staff then have to scan “every output” into the warehouse, shutting out invisible stock completely.
2. Automatic cost apportionment at preset ratios (cost apportionment)
This is the secret weapon Accounting is going to love! The ERP lets you define “cost-sharing ratios” in advance, for example 70% of the cost to chicken breast and 30% to wings. As soon as the run is complete, the system splits the cost of materials, labor, and overhead such as electricity, and automatically allocates it to each product according to the ratios you set, so every item carries its true cost.
3. Offset cost with revenue from saleable scrap (by-product recovery)
For “scrap” or very low-value by-products, such as metal offcuts, the ERP offers a by-product recovery function. When you weigh that scrap and sell it by the kilo, the system automatically takes the revenue and “deducts it from the cost of the main product.” The result is a lower main-product cost, giving you more room for margin.
Summary: every output has value, so don’t let any of it slip past you
With raw material costs volatile and competition fierce, a factory that can’t cost its co-products accurately throws away its pricing advantage. Using ERP software to manage multi-output BOMs makes Accounting’s job easier, keeps stock transparent, and turns the hidden value of “by-products” back into net profit for the company, in full.
Right now… how many hundreds of thousands of baht in “by-products” or “scrap” are gathering dust in your warehouse, invisible to your accounting system? Get a free consultation with manufacturing ERP specialists to set up cost apportionment and world-class co-product and by-product management!
References
- Horngren, C. T., Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2015). Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis. Pearson. (Cited for cost accounting theory, specifically the chapter on cost allocation for joint products and byproducts, and the method of allocating by market value at the split-off point.)
- Ptak, C. A., & Smith, C. (2011). Orlicky’s Material Requirements Planning. McGraw-Hill. (Cited for bill of materials (BOM) structures in the process industries and the handling of multi-output production.)