Skip to content

Insights

Producing for nothing and losing money on top! Plugging the leak with ECO management in ERP

blog

“An order of 10,000 units is boxed up and ready to be loaded onto the truck for the customer, when the QC manager comes running in to stop everything, shouting, ‘Hold the shipment! The hole position is off by 2 millimeters!’… When everyone starts looking for someone to blame, production insists, ‘I set up the machine exactly to the drawing,’ and holds up a crumpled paper work order. It turns out to be the old version of the drawing (Revision A), which engineering (R&D) had withdrawn and replaced with Revision B a month earlier!… All ten thousand units have to be scrapped on the spot.”

If “engineering changed the design, but nobody on the shop floor knew” is a nightmare that haunts your factory, you are not alone.

In industries where products are constantly being improved (such as electronics, automotive parts, furniture, or machinery), the bill of materials (BOM) and engineering drawings are the bible. But when a factory still relies on printing documents and handing them out, the disaster of out-of-sync information (information silos) is inevitable.

A critical leak: when production can’t keep up with R&D

Without an engineering change order (ECO) management system that connects the whole organization, you create financial black holes:

  • Producing to an obsolete revision in good faith: Line staff often set up machines using old work orders or drawings photocopied and kept in a drawer, with no idea that engineering changed the steel plate thickness spec only yesterday. The result is substandard work, and the entire batch gets rejected.
  • Dead stock from unplanned phase-outs: R&D switches to a new type of screw with immediate effect, regardless of the hundreds of thousands of old screws still sitting in the warehouse. The old materials become dead stock that will never be used again.
  • Approval bottlenecks: Before a new drawing can be released, someone has to carry a paper folder around collecting signatures from R&D, purchasing, planning, and the plant manager. Product improvements are delayed and fail to keep pace with customer demand.

One accurate version of the data: plugging the leak with ECO in ERP

Industry 4.0 factories won’t let a single sheet of paper decide the company’s profit. ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) software with ECO and BOM revision control turns scattered, inconsistent communication into a single source of truth, through three smart mechanisms:

1. Automatically locking old versions (automated revision control)

As soon as engineering approves version 2 of a BOM, the ERP immediately locks version 1! When planning releases a work order to the shop floor, the system automatically pulls in the version 2 BOM and the latest drawing and displays them on the technician’s computer or tablet. This completely eliminates the risk of technicians working from old drawings.

2. Managing material transitions (effectivity dates and phase-in/phase-out)

The ERP helps bridge the gap between R&D and the warehouse! When a component is changed, the system can be set to “use up the old part until stock runs out, then automatically start issuing the new part.” This feature clears old stock from the warehouse intelligently, without creating waste or tying up capital.

3. Real-time alerts for everyone involved (cross-functional digital workflow)

When an engineering change request (ECR) is raised, the system instantly notifies every department involved. Purchasing knows to stop ordering the old part, production knows to wait for the new drawing, and management can approve the change from their phones, so the production line keeps running without interruption.

Summary: control change, and you control profit

Improving and developing your products is a good thing, but if your back-office systems can’t keep up, those good intentions instantly turn into waste. Investing in ERP to manage engineering change orders (ECO) breaks down the walls between departments, establishes error-free communication, and ensures that… every one of the tens of thousands of units coming off the line matches the latest drawing exactly, down to the last millimeter!

The drawing your machine operators are holding right now… how sure are you that it’s the latest version? Put an end to out-of-spec production and upgrade your BOM revision management. Talk to our manufacturing ERP experts today!

References

  • Stark, J. (2015). Product Lifecycle Management: 21st Century Paradigm for Product Realisation. Springer. (Cited for product lifecycle management (PLM) theory and engineering change management processes that reduce production errors.)
  • Monk, E., & Wagner, B. (2012). Concepts in Enterprise Resource Planning (4th ed.). Cengage Learning. (Cited for the importance of BOM revision control in ERP systems and the effect of a centralized database on reducing the cost of excess stock.)

Back to all articles