Skip to content

Insights

Plug the raw material black hole with scrap and yield factors in your ERP BOM

blog

“Planning worked out the bill of materials (BOM) meticulously: a customer order for 10,000 pieces, each using 1 meter of steel sheet. To keep inventory costs down, purchasing ordered exactly 10,000 meters of steel… But once the machines were running, the operators had to trim off the ends (edge trimming), losing 2% of the steel, and machine setup ate up another 10 meters. In the end, only 9,790 pieces were produced, and the material was completely used up! Purchasing had to place a rush order for more steel at a steep price, and staff had to work overtime to finish the rest in time for the delivery truck.”

If “we ordered by the BOM, but it’s never enough for actual production” keeps happening in your factory, the problem isn’t that your machine operators are making mistakes, and it isn’t that your planners got the math wrong. It comes from pitting an idealized equation against real-world losses.

When a company runs on Excel files or legacy systems that always treat the bill of materials (BOM) as a strict 1:1 ratio, it inevitably ends up with bottlenecks that quietly erode profit.

The “guesswork” crisis: when the numbers on paper don’t match the shop floor

Failing to build normal process losses into material requirements planning causes 2 kinds of damage that take turns hurting the factory:

  • Ordering the exact amount = shortages on the line (Material Shortages): If you forget to account for the material lost during cutting and setup, or the scrap generated during forming, the material runs out before the production quantity is complete, causing downtime and damaging your reputation for on-time delivery.
  • Ordering extra “just in case” = bloated inventory (Dead Stock): After running short a few times, planners start adding a buffer based on gut feel, such as ordering an extra 10% on every order. The result is company capital tied up in surplus material gathering dust at the back of the warehouse.

Break through the limits of material planning with ERP scrap and yield functions

Modern manufacturers with sharp cost control don’t let anyone guess at buffer quantities. Instead, they use ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) software to keep the BOM as close as possible to the reality of the production line, through 3 powerful features:

1. Scrap captured at the component level (Component Scrap Percentage)

In production, some materials come with unavoidable losses (such as wire that has its insulation stripped, or film rolls that have to be cut away at the splices). The ERP system lets engineers enter a scrap percentage specific to each component directly in its BOM. When an order comes in, material requirements planning (MRP) automatically increases the gross requirement for that wire, so purchasing orders precisely enough to cover the expected loss.

2. Compensating for finished-goods yield (Assembly Yield Factor)

If your process carries a risk that finished products will fail final QC (for example, metal casting or electronics baking processes that consistently lose around 5%), you can set a yield factor of 95% in the ERP. When a customer orders 1,000 pieces, the ERP automatically creates a work order and issues materials for 1,053 pieces. That way, after the statistically expected scrap is deducted, you still have 1,000 good pieces to ship to the customer in full in a single run, without wasting power setting up the machines again for a make-up run.

3. Feeding actual scrap data back into the BOM (Actual Scrap Feedback Loop)

A modern ERP compares the scrap rate set in the BOM with the scrap operators actually scan out at the machine. If the system finds that scrap regularly exceeds the planned allowance, it immediately alerts management to review the process. Conversely, if scrap drops significantly, you can lower the scrap rate in the BOM to cut excess material purchases in the future.

Conclusion: good production planning must be grounded in reality

In manufacturing, supply chain management isn’t about who does the most precise arithmetic; it’s about who can most accurately build the real-world variability of the production process into the equation. Investing in ERP to manage component scrap and assembly yield will permanently eliminate “shortages on the line” and “overflowing warehouses” from your factory.

Pull out your factory’s latest BOM and take a look… are the material quantities in it what you actually use, or just idealized figures? Turn shop-floor losses into data you can plan with, and take your material requirements planning (MRP) to the next level. Talk to our manufacturing ERP specialists today!

Theoretical References

  • Ptak, C. A., & Smith, C. (2011). Orlicky’s Material Requirements Planning (3rd ed.). McGraw-Hill. (Cited for the theory of material requirements planning (MRP), the calculation of gross requirements, and the application of scrap and yield factors in product structures.)
  • Jacobs, F. R., Berry, W. L., Whybark, D. C., & Vollmann, T. E. (2011). Manufacturing Planning and Control for Supply Chain Management (6th ed.). McGraw-Hill. (Cited for the principles of managing planned yield loss to maintain service levels and prevent bottlenecks caused by material shortages on the production line.)

Back to all articles