Insights
Failed QC! Tackling the hidden cost of rework with ERP
blog
“QC has just rejected 500 units because they were assembled out of spec! Instead of packing the order for the customer, production has to take the whole batch back to ‘strip it down and redo it’ (rework). The knock-on effects: the next job on the line grinds to a halt, staff have to work overtime to fix the batch, and raw materials are pulled from the warehouse for repairs without being recorded…”
If this sounds like a regular occurrence in your factory, you are dealing with a black hole known as the Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ). In manufacturing, producing defects and throwing them away (scrap) is bad enough, but bringing defective goods back for rework causes even more chaos and does far more damage to your costing when there is no system in place to control it.
Where the money leaks when rework is managed on paper
Letting staff pull goods back for repair without raising a document in the system leads to structural losses:
- Overlooked labor and overhead: Reworking a single unit means the company pays for labor twice (once to make it, and again to fix it). Accounting is usually unaware of this, so the calculated product cost is lower than the real cost, and the more you sell, the more you lose.
- Stolen capacity: Machines and operators that should be working on new orders are tied up fixing old ones. The entire production schedule is thrown off, leading to late deliveries.
- Materials that vanish into thin air (inventory discrepancies): Repairs often need extra parts or materials. Line staff tend to “borrow” them from the warehouse without a proper material issue, so month-end stock counts are off and items go missing for no apparent reason.
Making rework transparent and auditable with ERP
Leading factories don’t let rework remain something only the shop floor knows about. They use an ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) system to map out and capture every cost involved, through the following mechanisms:
- A dedicated rework work order: As soon as QC rejects a batch, the system creates a rework work order, kept clearly separate from regular production orders. Management can see at a glance how many hours of resources went into rework today, and on which machines.
- Strict material issue for repairs: If extra screws or adhesive are needed for the repair, the ERP requires warehouse staff to issue them directly against the rework work order. Stock stays accurate, and accounting can capture this additional material cost precisely as part of the cost of waste.
- Scheduling rework around main production (dynamic scheduling): The ERP’s production planning slots rework jobs into the machine schedule intelligently, so that urgent priority orders are not affected. This reduces the scramble for machine time on the shop floor.
- Root cause analysis: The system requires a reason code every time a job is reworked. At month-end, management can pull a report straight away to see the most frequent causes of rework (for example, machines that have drifted out of setting, inexperienced new staff, or substandard materials from suppliers) and drive lasting improvements.
Some rework may be hard to avoid in any production process, but letting its cost “disappear into thin air” is entirely preventable. Using ERP to define and control the rework process lets you see your true costs, plug inventory leaks, and protect your factory’s profit in full.
References
- Crosby, P. B. (1979). Quality is Free: The Art of Making Quality Certain. McGraw-Hill. (Cited for the Cost of Poor Quality (COPQ) concept, including internal failure costs such as rework and scrap.)
- Datar, S. M., & Rajan, M. V. (2020). Horngren’s Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis. Pearson. (Cited for cost accounting principles on recording and allocating the costs of spoilage, rework, and scrap in job costing and process costing systems.)